Skip to content

Last updated: November 2026

Every credit card order at our bar carries a 3% surcharge. It is printed on our menu right beside the fish fry prices, and it is the reason our tip rail runs on Solana. When a customer asks why a bar in a village of 563 people bothers with a token, the answer is money. Card fees are real money when a two-piece cod dinner sells for $10.

That question, what a digital asset is actually worth to the person holding it, is the whole ballgame in the Zcash argument that landed this week.

Quick Answer: The Motley Fool’s Dominic Basulto argues Zcash beat Bitcoin and Ethereum over the past five years and could repeat it. The outperformance is real, but the window starts from a price already 95% below Zcash’s all-time high, so a 459% gain still leaves it 72% under that high. On Nov. 19, 2026, CoinGecko priced ZEC at $890, Bitcoin at $62,185 and Ethereum at $1,761.

What Did the Motley Fool Actually Argue About Zcash?

Basulto screened for coins above a $1 billion market cap and measured five-year returns. His finding, published Nov. 19, is that Zcash is up more than 300% over five years while Bitcoin gained 7% and Ethereum fell almost 60%. He then names three reasons the run could continue: privacy demand, a spot ETF, and a hard supply cap.

He also declines to take his own bait. The headline says Zcash could be the best crypto to hold, and the last section says he is still choosing Bitcoin. That is an honest column, and it is worth reading in full before you move a dollar.

What are the specific claims worth checking?

Four of them are checkable against primary and market data, so we checked them.

The supply cap

The Zcash project’s own economics page says it plainly: “Just like Bitcoin, Zcash has a fixed supply of 21 million coins.” Same monetary base, same halving rhythm. That claim holds.

The ranking

The column’s key points call Zcash a top-10 coin by market cap. CoinGecko’s table on Nov. 19 put it 11th at $15.2 billion, behind Hyperliquid at $16.0 billion. Eleventh is not tenth. It is close enough that it could flip by the time you read this, which is exactly why you check the table instead of the column.

The ETF

Basulto credits a Grayscale Zcash ETF, ticker ZCSH, and quotes Grayscale calling it one of the most successful new launches in a decade. We could not open Grayscale’s page to confirm the quote, because the site served a browser checkpoint instead of content. Treat that number as the fund company’s marketing claim, not an audited fact.

The five-year scoreboard

This is the one that needs a second price series rather than a source. On Nov. 19, 2021, Yahoo Finance priced ZEC at $158.94, Bitcoin at $58,119 and Ethereum at $4,298. Run those against today and the column’s figures reproduce almost exactly. Bitcoin is up 7.0% across that window and Ethereum is down 59.0%, which is what Basulto wrote. Zcash is up 459%, so his “more than 300%” is technically true and actually understated.

Now put that Zcash starting price next to the record. CoinGecko dates the all-time high to Oct. 28, 2016, at $3,191.93, which is the earliest date in its price series. A $158.94 entry point sits 95% below that high. Five years of winning still started from almost nothing. The measurement is accurate, the framing is generous, and both things are true at once.

What Are the Evaluation Criteria for a Five-Year Crypto Hold?

Five years is long enough that you will probably need the money at a bad moment. So we judge a hold on four things, in this order.

Can you get out without moving the price?

Zcash turned over about $790 million in the last 24 hours, according to CoinGecko. Bitcoin turned over $33.4 billion. If you ever need to sell a size that matters to your household, that ratio is what turns your exit into your loss.

Does the thesis survive a boring year?

Privacy demand is a real thesis. It is also the kind of thesis that a regulator can attack with one rule, which is why privacy coins carry a policy risk that Bitcoin does not.

Is the price already paying for the story?

ZEC is down 29.9% in 30 days and 40.0% in 60 days, per CoinGecko. That is a violent reversal inside a story about a coin going gangbusters.

How Does Zcash Compare on the Numbers That Matter?

MeasureZcash (ZEC)Bitcoin (BTC)Ethereum (ETH)
Price, Nov. 19, 2026$890$62,185$1,761
Market cap$15.2B$1.25T$215B
24-hour volume$0.79B$33.4B$10.8B
Price five years ago$158.94$58,119$4,298
Five-year return+459%+7.0%-59.0%
Last 30 days-29.9%-25.0%-28.3%
Gap to all-time high-72.1%-50.7%-64.4%
Supply cap21 million21 millionno hard cap
Bar chart of Zcash price at four checkpoints: $3,192 at the October 2016 all-time high, $159 at the start of the five-year window, $511 on January 1, 2026, and $890 on November 19, 2026
Zcash is up 459% over five years from a starting point already 95% below its 2016 peak. Sources: CoinGecko; The Motley Fool, Nov. 19, 2026.

Read the first and seventh rows together. Zcash has outperformed on a five-year clock and is still the furthest coin in this table from its own peak. Relative performance and absolute recovery are different questions, and only one of them pays your bills.

What Does a Privacy Coin Have to Do With a Prentice Bar?

More than you would guess. Our menu lists the Ripsaw Token and says “Tip your bartender with Solana.” That is a payment rail, not an investment thesis, and the distinction matters at a bar. A token that settles a tip in seconds is useful. A token you hold for five years is a bet.

We take the bet out of the transaction on purpose. Tips settle, drinks get poured, and nobody at the rail is checking a chart at 9 p.m. on a Friday. If you want to read how Wisconsin treats the reporting side of this, our guide to crypto security and taxes in Wisconsin covers record-keeping.

Why does the card surcharge matter here?

Because it is the smallest possible version of the same tradeoff Basulto is writing about. A 3% fee on a $10 check is 30 cents. Run that across a Friday fish fry in a village of 563 people and it becomes a line item you notice. Small margins are where payment choices stop being ideology.

Prentice had 563 residents in the 2020 census. At that scale a payment rail either settles or it does not, and nobody has the patience for a fourteen-minute confirmation while a bar back is waiting on the rail.

Which Crypto Fits the Most Common Need?

Most people asking this question are not building a five-year position. They are holding a little crypto and wondering where to put it. Ranked for that person:

  1. Bitcoin, for the boring majority. Deepest liquidity, longest record, and Basulto picks it over his own headline pick.
  2. Ethereum, for people who want the yield story. No hard cap, and it is down 64.4% from its August 2025 high, so the entry is not crowded.
  3. Zcash, for a small slice and a specific reason. Privacy is the reason. If you cannot state that reason out loud, you are buying a chart.
  4. Nothing, if the money is rent. A 40% drawdown in 60 days is survivable in a hobby account and not survivable in a car repair fund.

What Should You Avoid?

Do not buy a privacy coin because a headline called it the best hold for five years. The same column said the author was keeping Bitcoin. Do not treat an ETF launch as a floor under the price, because a fund that buys can also be sold. And do not size a position on the assumption that 21 million coins means scarcity you can bank on, since Zcash has had that cap since 2016 and still fell 72% from its high.

Verdict

Basulto’s column is worth your time and his five-year number is correct. The catch is the starting line. Zcash outperformed from a price already 95% below its peak, and it has given back 40% in the last two months. Hold a little if the privacy thesis is yours. Do not hold it because a screen said 300%.

We will be at 1117 Railroad Ave in Prentice at 2 p.m. Thursday, pouring Old Fashioneds with brandy and taking tips however you want to send them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Zcash actually up 300% over five years?

That is The Motley Fool’s figure, published Nov. 19, 2026, and it covers a five-year window ending this month. Yahoo Finance priced ZEC at $158.94 on Nov. 19, 2021, and CoinGecko puts it near $890 now, which works out to about 459%. So the column’s figure is conservative.

Why is Zcash still below its all-time high?

ZEC peaked at $3,191.93 on Oct. 28, 2016, per CoinGecko, the earliest date in its price series. At $890 it sits 72.1% under that level, so five strong years have not recovered the 2016 top.

Does Ripsaw Saloon accept crypto?

Our menu lists the Ripsaw Token and says you can tip your bartender with Solana. $RIP is accepted at the bar. It is a tip rail, not an investment product, and we do not sell coins to customers.

How much does a card order cost at Ripsaw?

A 3% surcharge is added to credit card orders, and menu prices already include tax. That is printed on the menu, not a policy we improvise at the register.

Sources